Fixing a Bad Bookkeeper's Work: How to Tell If Your Books Are Wrong and What Correcting Them Involves

Signs your previous bookkeeper got it wrong (unreconciled accounts, GST in revenue, missing payroll) and how corrections, amended returns and adjustments work.

Share
Online seller packing parcels at her home packing station

The quickest test of a previous bookkeeper's work: do the bank and credit card balances in your books match the statements at each month-end? If not, the books are wrong, and so may be the returns filed from them. Corrections usually mean reconciling, reclassifying and, where filed returns changed materially, adjusting them with the CRA.

Many owners only find out something was wrong when a new accountant opens the file, a lender asks for financial statements, or the CRA sends a letter that doesn't match what they thought was filed. This guide covers the warning signs, how to check the books yourself, how corrections are made, and when the CRA needs to be told.

Red flags

  • Bank or card accounts never reconciled, or "reconciled" with large unexplained adjustments
  • GST/HST collected sitting in revenue
  • Owner draws recorded as expenses
  • No payroll entries even though staff were paid
  • A huge "Ask My Accountant" or suspense balance
  • Loan payments booked entirely as expenses (principal isn't deductible)
  • Filed GST returns that don't match the books
  • Equipment and vehicles expensed in full instead of depreciated
  • Personal purchases mixed in with business expenses
  • Year-end balances that don't carry into the next year's opening balances

One of these on its own might be a small fix. Several together usually mean the books need a proper review before anything else is filed from them.

How to check your books in an afternoon

You don't need to be an accountant to spot most problems. Pull your bookkeeping software's balance sheet for the last day of a few recent months and compare:

  1. Bank and credit card balances against the actual statements for the same dates. They should match to the cent.
  2. GST/HST payable against what you filed and paid. If the balance keeps growing, or is negative for no clear reason, tax is being recorded in the wrong place.
  3. Payroll liabilities against your remittance history in My Business Account. Unpaid amounts sitting for months are a warning.
  4. Loans against the lender's statements. If the books show the original amount years later, payments were probably expensed.
  5. The shareholder loan account. A large or unexplained balance often hides personal spending or unrecorded owner pay.

If you can't log in to the CRA side, authorize a representative who can compare what was actually filed.

Why these mistakes matter

Bookkeeping errors don't stay in the software. Every return filed from wrong books is wrong too.

  • GST/HST in revenue overstates income, so the business may have paid too much income tax, while the GST/HST returns may have underreported tax collected.
  • Missing input tax credits mean the business paid more GST/HST than it owed. ITCs generally have to be claimed within four years for small businesses, so old ones can expire.
  • Unrecorded payroll means source deductions weren't remitted and T4s weren't issued. The CRA treats those deductions as trust money, and directors can be personally liable.
  • Expensed loan principal or equipment understates income in one year and distorts later years.
  • A messy shareholder loan can turn into personal income if it isn't sorted out in time.

How corrections work

  1. Reconcile everything from the earliest wrong period. Every bank, credit card, loan and payment platform account has to agree with its statements before anything else can be trusted.
  2. Reclassify what's mis-coded: tax in revenue, personal spending, loan principal, capital assets.
  3. Compare to filed returns. If tax changes, file amended returns: a T2 amendment, a T1 adjustment request, or a GST/HST adjustment (canada.ca, GST/HST adjustments). Payroll errors are corrected with amended T4s and, where needed, a late remittance.
  4. Consider VDP where the errors meant tax was underreported and the CRA hasn't been in touch. Our guide to the Voluntary Disclosures Program changes explains who qualifies.
  5. Fix the setup so it doesn't happen again: correct opening balances, a clean chart of accounts, bank feeds, and a monthly reconciliation routine.

If your old bookkeeper or accountant isn't handing over files, see how to get records from a previous accountant. If statements are missing, our guide to lost bank statements explains how to rebuild them.

Fix it or start over?

When the transactions were at least entered, correcting the existing file is usually faster. When the file is badly broken (years of unreconciled accounts, duplicate bank feeds, opening balances that never tied out) it can be quicker and cleaner to rebuild each year from the bank and card statements. A good bookkeeper will look at a few months before recommending one or the other. If the mess is DIY drift rather than a previous bookkeeper, our guide on outgrowing DIY QuickBooks or Xero covers the same cleanup from that angle.

What to ask your next bookkeeper

Before handing over the file, ask a few questions so the same problems don't come back:

  • Will every bank, credit card and loan account be reconciled each month, and will I see the reconciliation?
  • Who prepares and files GST/HST and payroll remittances, and how will I know they were filed on time?
  • How will owner pay and personal spending be recorded?
  • Will I get a monthly profit and loss statement and balance sheet I can actually read?

Clear answers to these questions are a better sign of quality than any software badge.

Example (hypothetical)

An Ontario agency at about seven figures found its previous bookkeeper had treated HST collected as income and claimed no input tax credits for two years. Correcting it reduced reported income, but the HST returns had underreported tax collected. Adjusted HST returns went in together with a VDP application, the T2 returns were amended, and the agency moved to monthly reconciliations so the next year end needed no clean-up.

Mistakes or something worse?

Most problems are inexperience, not fraud. A bookkeeper who was never trained on GST/HST or payroll can make the same mistake every month for years. If you suspect misappropriation (payments to unknown accounts, missing deposits, altered statements), keep copies of everything, change your banking and software access, and get legal advice before confronting anyone.

Getting it corrected properly

Sansar Solutions cleans up and corrects prior bookkeeping for entrepreneurs across Canada. We reconcile and reclassify, file the amended returns or adjustments, handle VDP where it fits, and set up monthly bookkeeping going forward. We charge one all-inclusive flat rate, with no hidden fees and no retainer: a 50% deposit to start and 50% on completion, after you approve your filings.

Learn more about our catch-up bookkeeping service, read whether bookkeeping clean-up services are worth it, or see how long catch-up bookkeeping usually takes.

Book a free call for a custom quote โ†’ ยท How onboarding works and what documents we need โ†’

If your bookkeeper has left and you are unsure where things stand, see what to do when your bookkeeper quits.

FAQ

How do I know if my books are wrong? Check whether bank and card balances in your books match each month-end statement. If they don't, something's wrong.

Do I have to amend returns if my bookkeeper made mistakes? If the errors changed the tax or GST/HST reported, yes. Corrections are filed with the CRA.

Will the CRA penalize me for my bookkeeper's errors? Penalties and interest can apply to underpaid tax. Correcting voluntarily, possibly through VDP, usually limits them.

Can I sue my old bookkeeper? Possibly, depending on the agreement and the harm. That's a legal question for a lawyer.

Is fixing books faster than starting over? Usually yes, if the transactions were at least recorded. Badly broken files are sometimes faster to rebuild from statements.


Written by Gurdeep Sangha, founder of Sansar Solutions, a Vancouver-based bookkeeping and tax firm serving small businesses across Canada (mainly Ontario, Alberta and BC). Bookkeeping and tax filing for business owners, without CPA-firm pricing. When you need a Notice to Reader or review engagement, we bring in our partner CPAs. This guide is general information, not tax or legal advice for your situation. Last reviewed: October 2026.